What Is Cheaper – Travelling in Ola, Uber or Buying a Car – A Comparative Analysis

At a press convention, on Tuesday, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman stated that one of the foremost factors at the back of the slowdown within the auto zone has been the change in the mindset of millennials.

According to Sitharaman, the youth in India might as an alternative opt for Ola, Uber and other cab offerings instead of paying EMI for a private car. This statement of her created an uproar among the millennial and industry specialists who said Ola, Uber and different trip-hailing offerings don’t have anything to do with the current enterprise slowdown.

India’s biggest automaker Maruti Suzuki contradicted Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman’s claim- “Ola and Uber got here into existence over the last 6-7 years. In this period, the car industry also saw some of its first-rate times. So, what came about most effective in the course of the previous couple of months that the downturn became so severe? I do no longer think it’s miles most effective because of Ola and Uber,” MSI Executive Director (Marketing and Sales) Shashank Srivastava.

But how actual is that this statement of Finance Minister is? Does journeying in Ola, Uber really make feel over shopping for a vehicle? The handiest way to find is to do a comparative analysis of Ride-hailing apps vs proudly owning a private vehicle:

1) There are innumerous trip-hailing apps, however, for reference, we will take India’s own OLA cabs

2) Since the maximum of the guests decide on Micro cab for the most inexpensive prices, they’re mainly Maruti Suzuki Wagon R. So it makes sense to evaluate Micro cab fare with owning a Wagon R

3) We will don’t forget a time frame of five years, traveling for 22 days a month for a 30 km each day run

four) The calculations are primarily based strictly on touring from domestic to office and back. No weekend touring or outdoor run has been included

5) Since the OLA operators ordinarily used basic motors, we can remember the bottom version of the Wagon R for comparison

Traveling through OLA

If you opt for Ola and the visiting distance is 30 km both side, you emerge as paying Rs 500 on an average (which includes a surcharge, MCD toll, parking, taxes, and the entirety).

On common, any worker is going to the workplace for 22 days, because of this the month-to-month expense is Rs 500*22 days = Rs eleven,000

5 Year rate would be = Rs eleven,000*60 Months = Rs 6.6 Lakh

Traveling thru Personal Car

The Maruti Suzuki Wagon R expenses begin at Rs four.34 Lakh (Ex-showroom, Delhi) for the base LXI 1.0-litre variant. The on-street fee in Delhi is Rs four. Eighty Lakh (can also vary from kingdom to nation).

If one avails a mortgage for five years at 9% hobby fee (current common bank price), they may grow to be paying Rs eighty-two,000 greater at the hobby (Down payment of Rs 1 Lakh, Loan on Rs three.34 Lakh, EMI of Rs 6,933). So the very last cost of the auto (excluding preservation value and carrier fee) will be Rs 5.62 Lakh.

A vehicle has to run on gasoline and Maruti Suzuki Wagon R grants 22.5 Kmpl mileage with the 1. Zero-litre petrol engine. The automobile will run for 30km* 22days* 60months = 39,600 Km in its lifespan.

Considering Rs seventy five as gasoline fee (common petrol charge in Delhi), the overall gas expenditure would be = 39,600/ 22.Five kmpl* Rs seventy five = Rs 1.32 Lakh.

This is difficult to alternate primarily based at the riding fashion. In practical conditions, Wagon R deliver 17-18 kmpl in city riding, with a purpose to increase the overall expenditure to Rs 1.6 Lakh.

Adding the value of owning the Wagon R with the gasoline price, you will become spending Rs 5.6 Lakh + Rs 1.6 Lakh = Rs 7.2 Lakh after 5 years.

On the alternative hand, one might argue that they would need to personal a CNG-equipped Maruti Suzuki WagonR for higher mileage (33 kmpl), the reality of the problem is. The initial value of the CNG car is higher than that of a petrol vehicle which could be Rs 6. Five lakh on-street, with a loan.

So after all of this, the final price ownership might turn out to be the identical = Rs 7.2 Lakh after five years. For each CNG and petrol vehicle.

Then there’s the coverage amount, that allows you to be delivered for the rest of the four years that’s Rs 60,000 (Rs 15,000*four).

There is also the upkeep cost which can not be mentioned as a selected price as it relies upon on the motive force’s using behavior as well as the street situations tackled in the course of an every day go back and forth, locality of residence for the car and additionally, the every day common strolling of the automobile for a whole lot of its possession duration. But for the sake of argument, if we consider the primary three offerings of the car to be unfastened and an annual expenditure of Rs 10,000 which includes such things as servicing, damage restore and other consumables like brake pads and lubricants. This could take the 5-12 months fee of protection to Rs 50,000 inside the aforementioned scenario taken by way of us for calculation functions.

However, the largest tremendous of owning a private car is the resale value which varies from model to version, yr of purchase, the year of producing of the automobile and also, the condition of the car. As in keeping with our research executed on diverse used automobile structures like Droom, the common price of a five-year antique WagonR with 40,000 km on the odometer turns out to be approximately Rs 3 lakh.

So you emerge as spending Rs 7.2 lakh (ownership fee) + Rs 50,000 (insurance cost) + Rs 60,000 (upkeep price) – resale price (Rs 3 lakh) = Rs 5.3 lakh.


While traveling the use of experience-hailing provider is cheaper through at the least Rs 50,000, it couldn’t be used as an everyday mode of transportation. There’s a hassle of finding the motors during rush hours, the automobiles are not smooth sufficient and there’s an effort to co-ordinate with drivers.

Also, our calculations are purely primarily based on the daily run to the office and again and don’t encompass enjoyment time on weekends. If you travel for the same and even an annual ride to nearby hill-station would make the personal vehicle more useful.

However the biggest poor against using a trip-hailing app is the general possession price of the auto and as we’ve got determined out, proudly owning an automobile is as a minimum Rs 1.3 lakh cheaper.

So while Nirmala Sitharaman isn’t wrong in announcing Millennial are increasingly preferring trip-hailing offerings for the tour, she is wrong in saying that it’s far ensuing in industry slowdown as

1) These services are generally availed through residents of Metro towns, and

2) One will defer their choice of purchasing a vehicle for waiting for the right automobile to return and use an experience-hailing service in the meantime, however, will not completely rely upon the identical.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *